Si-eun’s Revenge Debate: Core Fan Comments Compilation

Introduction

📍 As someone who creates content about Weak Hero, one of the most rewarding aspects is connecting with fellow core fans who share the same passion for this incredible drama. The thoughtful discussions and analyses that emerge from these interactions remind me why I fell in love with this story in the first place.

This compilation preserves some of the most insightful comments from my video 🔗 🎧 Does Si-eun’s Revenge Really Make No Sense? | Breaking Down the Si-eun Revenge Debate showcasing the depth of understanding and emotional investment that true fans bring to character analysis.

---

📢 Fair Use Notice

This post contains copyrighted material from “Weak Hero” (© Wavve/Netflix) used for educational analysis, criticism, and commentary purposes under fair use doctrine. All rights belong to original creators.

⚠️ I’ve noticed Korean fans reading my blog too, so sometimes I throw in Korean words to help them out – feel free to skip those parts!

The Literary Defense: Time Doesn’t Define Intensity

@elaine**** made a brilliant literary comparison that put the “40 days is too short” argument into perspective:

I don’t think we should listen to these objections. I just looked it up to confirm and in Romeo and Juliet, it’s apparently just 4 to 6 days from their falling in love up until their deaths. You know, so if Shakespeare can get away with that in what is generally considered a masterpiece… I think WHC should be allowed to have Si-eun go on a rampage after a whole 40 days.

---

이런 반대 의견들을 들을 필요 없다고 생각해. 확인해보니 로미오와 줄리엣에서는 사랑에 빠진 후 죽음까지 겨우 4-6일밖에 안 걸렸대. 그러니까 셰익스피어가 일반적으로 걸작으로 여겨지는 작품에서 그런 걸 해낼 수 있었다면… 약한영웅도 40일 후에 시은이 복수에 나서는 걸 허용받아야 한다고 생각해.

This perfectly captures why the time criticism falls flat when we consider how masterful storytelling has always prioritized emotional truth over arbitrary timelines.

Understanding Si-eun’s Psychology: The Perfectionist’s Breaking Point

@zeynepo***** provided one of the most insightful character analyses in the comments:

I’ve always thought it’s totally normal for his personality. Si-eun is a perfectionist and very hard-working person. He builds something, he sacrifices a lot and when it’s damaged, he gets crazy. First he was up to college. When Yeong-bin said ‘Don’t tell teacher, our notes will be affected by it’ he kept silent. He asked them to stop, tried his best and after all that he had one scratch on his work, he went crazy. Then he had friends; he asked Beom-seok to stop. He got beaten up, sacrificed. And now it’s not only a scratch, it’s his all he has… His explosion is not only because he cares too much for Su-ho but he tried so hard to protect his new ‘masterpiece.’ I see it like that.

---

나는 항상 그의 성격상 완전히 정상적이라고 생각했어. 시은은 완벽주의자이고 매우 열심히 하는 사람이야. 뭔가를 만들고, 많은 것을 희생하다가 그게 망가지면 미쳐버리는 거지. 처음에는 대학 진학이 목표였어. 영빈이 ‘선생님께 말하지 마, 우리 내신에 영향 갈 거야’라고 했을 때 그는 침묵했지. 그만하라고 요청하고, 최선을 다했는데 결국 자신의 작품에 흠집 하나가 생기자 미쳐버렸어. 그 다음에는 친구들이 있었고, 범석에게 그만하라고 요청했지. 맞고, 희생했어. 그런데 이번에는 단순한 흠집이 아니라 자신이 가진 전부였어… 그의 폭발은 수호를 너무 아끼기 때문만이 아니라 자신의 새로운 ‘걸작’을 보호하려고 너무 열심히 노력했기 때문이야. 나는 그렇게 봐.

My response: “No matter how much I think about it, this drama is so beautiful because it doesn’t rush to capture the boys’ dam-bursting emotions with just one single word… That’s probably why we get all these amazing comments, right? If there was one phrase that could capture the boys’ emotions, it would have to be ‘first love,’ just like Director Yoo Su-min said.”

“아무리 생각해봐도 이 드라마가 아름다운 이유는 소년들의 터져나오는 감정을 단 하나의 단어로 성급하게 포착하려 하지 않기 때문이야… 그래서 이런 놀라운 댓글들을 받게 되는 것 같아, 그렇지? 만약 소년들의 감정을 포착할 수 있는 한 마디가 있다면, 유수민 감독이 말한 것처럼 ‘첫사랑’ 이어야 할 거야.”

@zeynepo***** replied: “Exactly. It’s the interaction of complex feelings and different personalities. Their relationships have so many dimensions to explore. And I enjoy that.”

The Parallel Pain: Si-eun and Beom-seok’s Shared Trauma

@kirethomas***** highlighted the crucial parallel between Si-eun and Beom-seok’s reactions:

This is exactly what Beom-seok meant when he told Si-eun that he should understand more than anyone why he did what he did. You literally stated it, that Su-ho was the only light in Si-eun’s life after only knowing darkness. Both Si-eun and Beom-seok actually have the same reaction to losing that light except the method is specific to the character’s psychosis.

---

이게 바로 범석이 시은에게 ‘누구보다도 왜 그런 일을 했는지 이해해야 한다’고 말한 것의 의미야. 네가 말한 그대로, 수호가 어둠만 알고 살던 시은의 삶에서 유일한 빛이었거든. 시은과 범석 모두 실제로 그 빛을 잃는 것에 대해 똑같은 반응을 보였어. 다만 방법이 각 캐릭터의 정신병리에 따라 달랐을 뿐이지.

My response: “I’ve seen fans joke ‘we want to ask Su-ho how it feels to be loved by two psychos’ and I found it absolutely hilarious.” (😂)

This comment brilliantly captures the tragic symmetry of the story – both boys loved Su-ho desperately and both reacted violently to losing him, just in different ways.

The Acting That Sells the Story

@margarethale-******* touched on a crucial point about believability:

It may be overdone, but Park Ji-hoon’s and Hyun-wook’s acting all throughout the drama made it valid.

My response: “You’re absolutely right. Director Yoo Su-min always talks about Park Ji-hoon as ‘an actor who convinces you of everything just by watching his performance’ and he’s constantly praising Choi Hyun-wook too. Speaking of which, the director said about Choi Hyun-wook… there’s a recent magazine interview where the director said ‘I like vulnerable moments when his character is hurt or injured in the drama’ and I think I totally get what he means. There’s something about watching Hyun-wook bleeding or in fight scenes in the drama that’s just so sexy.”

@margarethale-******** replied: “I know right? Ji-hoon killed that stoic character portrayal but Hyun-wook is just so alluring when he is dodging punches.“

My follow-up: “Exactly! I was completely hooked on Si-eun when he stabbed Tae-hoon’s hand with a pen and wrapped Yeong-bin’s face with the curtain before smashing him with a book and Su-ho… wow, I totally fell in love during his action scenes! I heard that Choi Hyun-wook actually has great reflexes because he was an athlete in real life.”

The Emotional Authenticity Debate

@parkmi-ni-** captured the core argument perfectly:

“I personally think that was the most valid crash out I have ever seen. Maybe we would have done the same if we were in his place too. Imagine losing the only light that finally entered your life after years of loneliness.“

@juhim**** expanded on this beautifully:

“Honestly for someone saying that his emotional outburst was unwanted didn’t catch the beauty of these raw emotions that were portrayed just as you said. Time doesn’t determine your connection to a person. If that person is someone who gets you, fulfills you, it will just take 10 days or even less than that… honestly Su-ho makes me yearn for that kind of friendship pure without any fabrication, just pure love.“

---

“솔직히 그의 감정적 폭발이 원하지 않는 것이라고 말하는 사람들은 네가 말한 대로 묘사된 이런 날것의 감정들의 아름다움을 놓쳤어. 시간이 사람과의 연결을 결정하지 않아. 그 사람이 너를 이해하고, 너를 충족시켜주는 사람이라면 10일, 아니 그보다도 적게 걸릴 거야… 정말 수호는 그런 종류의 우정에 대한 갈망을 느끼게 해 – 어떤 꾸밈도 없이 순수한, 그냥 순수한 사랑.“

My response: “While talking with my friends I almost asked them ‘If we’ve been friends for like 4000 days and I fell into a coma, could you do what Si-eun did?’” 😂

The Symbolic Storytelling Details

@margarethale-******* noticed brilliant narrative parallels:

I love the fact that the beginning of the drama, he got the answers wrong because he was bullied. An event he had gone through and completely deflected and avoided. But in the end, he got wrong answers in the final exams, not because he blocked the person who caused it but because he was deeply involved and emotionally invested in him.

---

드라마 초반에 그가 괴롭힘 때문에 문제를 틀렸다는 사실이 좋아. 그가 겪은 사건을 완전히 회피하고 피했던 거지. 하지만 마지막에는 기말고사에서 문제를 틀렸는데, 그 원인이 된 사람을 차단했기 때문이 아니라 그 사람에게 깊이 개입되고 감정적으로 투자했기 때문이야.

My response: “Exactly… These little directing details like that are what stick with us for so long…“

The Age and Cultural Context

@manelbenchaoui**** brought up important context about their ages and timeline:

Awesome analysis, they were 15 years old so everything was more intense. But I didn’t know all the events in the first season happened within 40 days, always thought it was like 4 months, at least 3 months. 40 days is kinda short especially they didn’t see each other every day, so I don’t know… Excuse my delulu but 40 days would be more coherent if romantic feelings were involved.

My response: “Haha yes delulu always makes me laugh! That’s actually why I made this video today. My friends… (my friends around me) kept arguing that it doesn’t make sense for Si-eun to explode like that after only being friends for 41 days. So I made this and now I feel like I’ve totally gotten it all out of my system.”

I also clarified the age issue: “Originally Korea had this weird age counting system where you’re one year old as soon as you’re born, which was totally stupid… But recently the old president abolished that weird age counting law during his term and changed it so you start at 0 when you’re born, so my age went down by two years too. In the show, Si-eun, Su-ho, and Beom-seok all appear as 17 years old, I confirmed it in the script.”

The Realism vs. Emotional Truth Debate

Throughout the comments, there was an ongoing theme about nitpicking realistic details versus accepting emotional truth. As I mentioned to several subscribers:

I have friends who always nitpick about realism in fantasy shows while we’re watching together and it’s so annoying. I saw this on Twitter where some Weak Hero fan was watching with their nurse sister, and during Su-ho’s coma scene where he’s on the ventilator, the sister looked at the oxygen machine and was like ‘His vitals look way too normal though?’ Totally killed the mood, but that story was actually hilarious. 😂

@juhim**** had medical knowledge to share: “Actually for someone who is in a coma for that long I think he was supposed to be put on an invasive mechanical ventilation even a tracheostomy but oh well we can just ignore those details.“

There’s something beautifully meta about discussing how nitpicking details can ruin the emotional experience while simultaneously nitpicking medical details in the comments!

The Fandom’s Lasting Impact

@farnaaazmansooori**** expressed what many core fans feel:

I love your analysis please don’t stop them. I know it’s hard cause after some time there will be nothing to discuss and analyze but still though… I’m getting over the pain of not having these characters until season 3 comes out only through your videos.

My response: “I’ll probably be the last person to get discharged from the psych ward (I’ve seen way too many comments from people who watched it 3 years ago and are still obsessing over it) so I definitely won’t run out of things to talk about.”

@zeynepo***** perfectly captured the addictive nature of this drama:

“Take me for example: I was totally unaware of this drama in March, and now I am obsessed with it. I devoured it in 10-20 days and it’s taken me as a hostage.“

@8A22AyushiBanerjee-***** responded: “Don’t worry dude… I got you (being held hostage for 2.5 years now).“

There’s also the ongoing mystery that @beatriza***** brought up about Beom-seok’s fate, leading to my clarification about the “Next Actor” magazine interview where Director Yoo Su-min mentioned that “Beom-seok probably learned a lot from that incident and is full of regret. And as you know, Su-ho’s financial situation isn’t good, so Beom-seok is probably living in the Philippines, listening to his adoptive father like he said he would, even if it’s just to help with Su-ho’s hospital bills.”

Conclusion

These comments remind me why I’m so passionate about creating content around Weak Hero. The depth of analysis, emotional investment, and genuine understanding that core fans bring to these discussions is what makes this community so special. Whether we’re debating the realism of medical equipment, comparing the story to Shakespeare, or analysing the psychology behind teenage emotional explosions, these conversations preserve the magic of what makes this drama so compelling.

Thank you to everyone who takes the time to share such thoughtful insights. These exchanges with fellow fans are what keep the story alive long after the credits roll.

🔗 Related Posts by Character & Language

📚 Si-eun (시은) Analysis

English Posts

• Si-eun’s Episode 8 Revenge: Why the “Implausible” Critique Completely Misses the Point
• Why Si-eun is a Character Magnet: The Psychology Behind Weak Hero’s Most Compelling Relationships
• Si-eun’s Hidden Violence: An Exploration
• Si-eun’s Revenge Debate: Core Fan Comments Compilation

---

🥊 Su-ho (수호) Analysis

English Posts

• Su-ho’s Lost Comedy Gold: The Wordplay That Made Weak Hero Fans Fall in Love (But English Subtitles Missed Everything)
• The Untold Story of Su-ho and Beom-seok: Why Their Friendship Was Doomed from the Start

Korean Posts

• 수호와 범석의 더욱 깊은 이야기: 시네마틱 트라우마를 남기기까지한 그 ‘링’ 장면에 이르기까지 두 소년의 이야기

---

💔 Beom-seok (범석) Analysis

English Posts

• When Dreams Become Prison: Analyzing Beom-seok’s Boxing Ring Appearance in Si-eun’s Dreams
• When Subscribers Become Psychology Experts: Two Brilliant Takes on Why Beom-seok Destroyed Su-ho in That Ring
• Beom-seok’s Obsession with Su-ho: The Tragic Psychology Behind Weak Hero’s Most Complex Relationship

---

⚡ Seong-je (성제) Analysis

English Posts

• The Romantic Chaos of Geum Seong-je: Why Weak Hero Class 2’s Most Dangerous Character Became Its Most Beloved

---

🤝 Character Dynamics

English Posts

• Su-ho and Si-eun’s Relationship: When Fans Ask the Hard Questions About Weak Hero’s Most Debated Bond
• Understanding Yeong-i: The Character Who Reveals Everything About Weak Hero’s Heart
• Was Yeong-i Added to Tone Down the Bromance? When Subscribers Drop Literary Masterpieces in My Comments
• Jun-tae’s Japanese Mystery and the Heartwarming Go-tak Friendship in Weak Hero Class 2

---

🎭 Behind-the-Scenes & Analysis

English Posts

• Weak Hero Class 1 Script Book: Behind-the-Scenes Secrets That Will Change How You See the Show
• Script Book vs Final Cut: The Dream Scene That Made Us All Cry
• The Complete Behind-the-Scenes Story of Weak Hero Class 1 – Answering Subscriber Questions
• Weak Hero Class Change Video Explanation: Actors Switching Roles
• Weak Hero Deleted Scene Delivery! Beuksan High’s #1 Taking Down Bullies

---

🌍 Fan Community & Cultural Analysis

English Posts

• Weak Hero Fans Are Going INSANE and I’m Here for It: The Comments That Broke My Brain
• The Joy of Global Connection: Discussing Weak Hero’s Most Complex Relationships with Fans Around the World
• When International Fans Decode Korean Bromance: Why Weak Hero Reads as BL Overseas
• Three Questions That Reveal Weak Hero’s Hidden Korean Realism
• Why These Three Friends Always Sit Together During Exams (And Other Translation Secrets)

Korean Posts

• 전 세계 약한영웅 팬들과 이 작품을 오랫동안 기억하는 즐거움 이상의 기쁨

---

📊 Quick Navigation by Interest

⚡ Character Dynamics:

• Su-ho and Si-eun’s Relationship
• Beom-seok’s Obsession with Su-ho
• When International Fans Decode Korean Bromance

🧠 Psychology Deep Dives:

• When Subscribers Become Psychology Experts
• Si-eun’s Episode 8 Revenge
• Why Si-eun is a Character Magnet

🎬 Behind-the-Scenes Content:

• Script Book Secrets
• Script Book vs Final Cut
• Deleted Scenes

🌐 Translation & Cultural Context:

• Su-ho’s Lost Wordplay
• Translation Secrets
• Korean Realism